Wait A Minute

The first time you hear a new name, there’s a pretty good chance you won’t like it. We should probably reinforce that more often. You know, when you heard Kraft split and called their snack business Mondelez – what was that?  Or when 3M spun off its healthcare division and called it Solventum – I think we are still getting used to that name.

Naming is one of the more interesting things we do at Catapult. It’s a pretty fun activity for everyone – as we have developed a solid process that’s matured over the years. There is a notion that coming up with creative or novel names is challenging. But in reality, developing names is the easy part – especially if you have a clear brief and attributes the name needs to embody. The real challenge is vetting names and getting them through an organization.

[The vetting process involves trademark and Google searches to understand if the name is “owned” and if there are any negative associations. And that usually kicks out a lot of names. But that’s a topic for another post.]

In branding, we ask our clients to react to something completely unfamiliar – like a logo or name. It’s a hard thing to do. Especially since we have only been working with them for a week or so. It takes time to get used to seeing, saying or hearing a name. We know this all too well. When Catapult Thinking was new, even we had to get used to saying it. There were plenty of phone calls where “Catapult Thinking” came out a little more jumbly than it does now. Cat-a-pult. Think-ing. Two words. Five syllables. Please hold.

After a while, you stop thinking about it. Your mouth figures it out. Your ear figures it out. The name stops being a collection of sounds and starts being the name of the thing. It takes time. But all too often people nix a name too quickly – and usually for personal reasons. This is when we ask them to take a day or two with it. This happened when we renamed payment company Merchant Warehouse to Cayan. Their investors thought the name would be confused with the Porsche Cayenne SUV – because 3 of them had owned one. The name ticked a lot of boxes: no trademark, url availability, and implied a “hot company” in the fast-moving payment processing space (they were acquired a year after the rebrand for a billion dollars).

Heck, they had a competitor named Square. Square is a good example of how names can take on new meaning – even if it had a negative connotation to overcome – the nerdy, “be there or be square.” There are tons of examples of this. Amazon doesn’t immediately make you think of a rainforest anymore. Target is a completely normal place to buy toothpaste. Caterpillar can sell heavy construction equipment without anyone wondering why it’s named after a bug. And The Cheesecake Factory doesn’t find having cheesecake in their name limiting (with over 250 items) and no one thinks of it as a dimly lit factory. We always say, “you can be 80% right, but you need to be 100% consistent.” That is how names take on meaning. A Roomba is a robotic vacuum. The Apple Store doesn’t sell fruit.

That doesn’t mean gut reactions are useless. If a name creates a genuinely bad association (like it is a type of herpes—true story), or it’s very difficult to pronounce, or connotes an attribute that is wrong for the brand. But “I don’t know, it sounds weird” is different. Sometimes weird just means new. The first reaction to a name can tell you something. It just shouldn’t tell you everything. That’s why one of the hardest parts of naming is getting past the instinct to immediately sort everything into LIKE and DON’T LIKE. And another mantra we say here is, “we are not in the ‘like’ business.” We look for the rationale, rather than a personal bias. And it happens. People check names with a friend, a spouse, or a new employee without any background or rationale.

A name is only one part of the equation. What really matters is what gets wrapped around it. The identity. The product. The packaging. The advertising. The voice. The customer experience. The content and the experience that brings it to life.

That’s also why we don’t evaluate names completely in isolation. A name gets more interesting when you start putting a world around it. Type it out. Say it in a sentence. Put it on the package. Imagine somebody answering the phone with it. Write a headline underneath it. Make fake advertisements. All this gives names legs. Some names get better very quickly once you do that. Others start to fall apart. Both are useful. What isn’t particularly useful is staring at a list of names on a slide and waiting for one of them to create the same emotional response as a brand you’ve known since childhood.

That’s a pretty high bar for a Tuesday afternoon meeting.

And then there’s the internet. A company announces a new name or identity at 9:00 in the morning and by 9:07 the internet has reached a verdict. The screenshots are out. The jokes are rolling in. Somebody has already put the old logo next to the new one. Someone else wants everyone involved fired. Pitchforks move fast now. (And sometimes the criticism is deserved.)

But there’s also something strange about treating the first few hours of unfamiliarity as proof that something has failed. Of course, the new thing feels different from the old thing. That was sort of the point. A good name doesn’t always walk into the room and introduce itself as a good name. Sometimes it needs a little time.

I remember back in the day when Andersen Consulting split off a company called Accenture and GTE (where I worked) changed to Verizon. I asked myself; how long will it take to get used to the names. It happens, and it doesn’t take so long. But it takes more than a minute. I have to think next year we’ll get used to Solventum — but today it’s a rather clumsy name that is hard to spell and hear.

Let’s Talk Brand Strategy
617.350.5277  x25

 

 

Brand Strategy / Brand Architecture / Positioning / Product Line Logic
Naming / Research / Brand Identity / Packaging / Brand Guidelines